top of page

Everything but the Kitchen Sink: Writing your Job Description – How much is too much?

In a tight labor market, where there is strong competition for qualified candidates, the general rule of thumb is that it's advisable to provide more detail in your job ad. While a detailed job ad can help attract the right candidates by providing them with a clear understanding of the role, responsibilities, and qualifications required, there is a downside to too much information.

Here’s a summary of the benefits and draw backs of providing more rather than less detail in your job advertisement. 1.Attracting the Right Candidates: Detailed job descriptions help potential candidates understand the specific skills and qualifications needed for the position. This can attract candidates who are a better fit for the role, reducing the number of unqualified applicants. 2.Transparent Expectations: Providing a comprehensive job description helps set realistic expectations for candidates regarding the responsibilities, work environment, and potential challenges associated with the role. This transparency can contribute to higher job satisfaction and retention. 3.Time-Saving: A detailed job ad can discourage unqualified candidates from applying, saving your hiring team time in the initial screening process. It allows candidates to self-select based on their qualifications and interest. 4.Showcasing Company Culture: Including information about your company culture, values, and work environment can help candidates assess whether they would be a good fit. This can be especially important in a competitive market where candidates have options. 5.Competitive Edge: A well-crafted, detailed job ad can make your company stand out. It demonstrates that your organization values transparency and is serious about finding the right candidate. This can be a competitive advantage in attracting top talent. All that said, it's possible to put too much detail in a job ad limiting the number of candidates who apply, and, in our experience, potentially eliminating applications all together. This is particularly noticeable in today’s hyper competitive environment for qualified and experienced Aesthetic Professionals.

While providing a detailed job description can be beneficial, excessive information can have significant drawbacks: 1.Overwhelming Content: If a job ad is overly lengthy or contains an excessive amount of information, it may overwhelm potential candidates. People may be discouraged from applying if they feel they need to sift through a lot of details to understand the core aspects of the job. 2.Detailed Requirements: Extremely specific or extensive lists of qualifications and requirements discourages potentially qualified candidates from applying if they feel they don't meet every single criterion or if they are left with the impression that the work environment is micromanaged. This is a common problem resulting from the nature of the relationship between physicians and nurses in the primary care environment. Keep in mind that many Aesthetic Practitioners have left primary care specifically to get away from this dynamic, so any hint of an overbearing relationship with the physician is off-putting and can lead to a smaller pool of applicants. This is perhaps the most common mistake we see from employers in our work. 3.Legal and Ethical Concerns: Including too much detail about the job may inadvertently introduce discriminatory language or requirements, which could raise legal or ethical concerns. It's important to ensure that your job ad complies with anti-discrimination laws. 4.Lack of Flexibility: Providing an exhaustive list of duties and qualifications may make the role seem rigid. Some candidates may be hesitant to apply if they believe there's little room for flexibility or growth in the position. See item 2 above. To optimize your job ad, focus on providing enough information to attract the right candidates without overwhelming them. Here are some tips: Highlight Key Responsibilities: Emphasize the most critical responsibilities and tasks associated with the role. Prioritize Essential Qualifications: Clearly outline the must-have qualifications while allowing for some flexibility with desirable skills. Convey Company Culture Concisely: Instead of providing an exhaustive overview, succinctly communicate the company culture, values, and work environment. Encourage Applications: Use inclusive language that encourages a diverse range of candidates to apply. Avoid overly restrictive language that might discourage potentially qualified individuals. Provide Contact Information: If candidates have questions or need clarification, encourage them to reach out for more information. In summary, finding the right balance between providing sufficient detail and avoiding information overload is crucial to attract a diverse pool of qualified candidates. In today’s hyper competitive environment, we recommend keeping the job ad somewhat general to attract as wide a pool of candidates as possible while remaining flexible in your expectations and being open to working around candidates specific skill sets. Hire attitude and train the rest as the old saying goes.


bottom of page